Argument the draft was unconstitutional under the

Argument EssayThroughout United States History, the military draft has been installed in times of war. While some may support the draft, many are opposed, and for good reason. There are individuals who want to join the army, who feel it is their duty to fight for and protect their country, however those who do not wish to do so should not be forced into it. While the draft is not currently active, from time to time there is conversation about bringing it back. Nonetheless, reinstating conscription would divide US society interminably. If you look back at American history, conscription has never been successful, but instead as David Greenberg argues, “has always been divisive, and not, as draft supporters claim, a unifying experience” (text 1, paragraph 1). In the past, when the United States would draft young men into the army, often times the rich would either pay poor minorities to take their place, so they did not have to go and fight or buy their way out of service for $300 Right there is a division of society between upper and lower class, a division that lead to fatal riots. Charlie Rangel wrote “white Americans could sip cocktails, just like plantation owners sipped mint juleps”. (text 1 paragraph 8)  On another occasion, vigilantes tormented and shamed individuals into serving. In 1918, the government was sued under the argument that the draft was unconstitutional under the 13th amendment, however the Supreme Court maintained that it was constitutional.  Argument Essay
Throughout United States History, the military draft has been installed in times of war. While some may support the draft, many are opposed, and for good reason. There are individuals who want to join the army, who feel it is their duty to fight for and protect their country, however those who do not wish to do so should not be forced into it. While the draft is not currently active, from time to time there is conversation about bringing it back. Nonetheless, reinstating conscription would divide US society interminably.

If you look back at American history, conscription has never been successful, but instead as David Greenberg argues, “has always been divisive, and not, as draft supporters claim, a unifying experience” (text 1, paragraph 1). In the past, when the United States would draft young men into the army, often times the rich would either pay poor minorities to take their place, so they did not have to go and fight or buy their way out of service for $300 Right there is a division of society between upper and lower class, a division that led to fatal riots. Charlie Rangel wrote “white Americans could sip cocktails, just like plantation owners sipped mint juleps”. (text 1 paragraph 8) On another occasion, vigilantes tormented and shamed individuals into serving. In 1918, the government was sued under the argument that the draft was unconstitutional under the 13th amendment, however the Supreme Court maintained that it was constitutional.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!


order now

In the end, this will never be a topic agreed upon by everybody. There are many points each side can use to argue, and there most likely will not be a definitive conclusion anytime in the near future. It is my hope however that more people are educated on the issue and understand that while it can be convincing to reinstate the draft, it’s outcome would only increasingly divide US society.

Go Top
x

Hi!
I'm Rita!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out