Imagine farm is perfect. There is enough

Imagine a world in the way we farm is perfect. There is enough food supply for the entire population, farm workers have excellent living and working conditions, and there is no underlying structural racism in our food system. Sadly, this is hardly the case for America’s current farming practices as a result of many factors. The readings, “This Land Is Whose Land? Dispossession, Resistance, and Reform in the United States”, by agroecologist Eric Holt-Giménez, “Workers On Organic Farms Are Treated As Poorly As Their Conventional Counterparts” by Jason Mark, and “Produce Industry Promises to Improve Mexican Farmworker Conditions” by Los Angeles Times writer Richard Marosi all discuss this similar topic of the way America farms. The common issue between these articles being how concentrated power in the farming industry has continually put immigrants, people of color, and women at a disadvantage. Through authors such as Holt-Giménez, Marosi, and Mark, the complexity of the issue of global farming monopolies can be shown by the history in the way we farm, the working/living conditions of immigrant farm workers, and the structural racism found in our food system. Though they have similar ideas, they go about it in a different way. For example, Marosi, in his writing brings attention to the often unknown mistreatment of Mexican farm workers and the poor living and working conditions they’re forced to endure. He speaks of the harsh reality of what it’s like to work on a farm, stating, “thousands of farmworkers lived in rat-infested labor camps, often without beds or reliable water supplies, and had their pay illegally withheld” (Marosi). Unfortunately, these working situations have gone largely unnoticed mainly because larger farms haven’t been held accountable for their actions. This conversation has only now been brought to our attention due to the Los Angeles Times conducting an investigation exposing this ugly truth. As a response to this publication, farming companies have put into place an alliance that will hopefully improve working conditions. However, this resolution doesn’t consider any input from the actual farm workers themselves and has “drawn critical reactions from growers and top federal and state officials…,  dismissing the coverage as an effort to harm the Mexican farm economy on behalf of growers in California and Florida” (Marosi). Large farms and government officials have continuously used their power as means to silence and take advantage of Mexican farm workers. Even in their “attempts” to come up with a solution to poor labor conditions, farming industries still find a way to contribute to the mistreatment of immigrants. This half thought out plan clearly shows that they clearly value profit over the wellbeing of their staff. The fact global farming monopolies have been allowed to get away with the inhumane treatment of their workers for this long shows that they hold too much power and ignorance of the public. Additionally, Mark argues about the “disconnect between reality and public perception is of increasing concern to farmworker advocates”. Mark provides evidence for his claim by using one woman’s experience of what it’s actually like working on a farm, stating, “supervisors at her farm… were often ‘aggressive’ and capricious… There was an atmosphere of fear. People were afraid they would be laid off “.Finally, Holt-Giménez argues the issue of land grabbing and how it has ultimately led to the contribution to the structural racism in our food system, targeting immigrants, people of color, and women.  Eric Holt-Giménez goes about arguing his point in an interesting, different way. He uses the historical perspective of land dispossession as evidence, discussing how the way we farm has changed over the years and how that is different from how it’s changing now. He states, “Today’s agrarian transition is about the countryside’s role in the rise of agri-food monopolies” (Holt-Giménez 252). Also, the tone of each piece are all similar. Holt-Giménez and Marosi being serious and informational, while Mark was more informal. Through the various articles, it’s clear the authors take a similar stance against the concentrated power of bigger farms and organizations that contribute to racism that can be food system. The complexity can be shown by the many factors that contribute to this issue, whether it’s mistreatment of Mexican farmworkers, ignorance of the public, or the structural racism built into the farming industry

Go Top
x

Hi!
I'm Rita!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out